Water Heater: Repair or Replace?
A water heater is an essential component in your home that provides you with hot water for various household tasks. From taking a warm shower to washing dishes, we rely on our water heaters every day. However, like any other appliance, water heaters have a limited lifespan and will eventually need to be repaired or replaced. The decision to repair or replace your water heater can be a tough one. On one hand, repairing the existing unit may seem like the more cost-effective option in the short term. But at some point, frequent repairs and maintenance costs may add up and make replacing the unit a more practical choice.
In this article, we'll discuss when it's best to repair or replace your water heater, along with the factors you should consider when making this decision.
Repairing Your Water Heater
If your water heater is relatively new (under four years old) and has been experiencing minor issues, such as a leaky valve or a faulty thermostat, it may be more sensible to repair it rather than replace it. These repairs are often quick and affordable, and can extend the lifespan of your water heater for several more years. Another reason to consider repairing your water heater is if you have a unique unit that cannot be easily replaced. For example, if you have a solar-powered or tankless water heater, finding a suitable replacement can be challenging and expensive. In such cases, repairing your existing unit may be the best option.
Do You Have a Water Heater Warranty?
Before deciding to repair your water heater, check if it is still under warranty. If the unit is covered by a manufacturer's warranty, you may be able to get repairs done at little or no cost to you. However, keep in mind that warranties typically have limited coverage and may not cover all types of damage or breakdowns.
Water Heater Replacement
According to Forbes, water heater failures can be costly, averaging $4,444 per incident. Though initially expensive, a new heater can save money through fewer repairs and better energy efficiency. In fact, newer models are built to be more energy-efficient, with some consuming 14% less energy than older models. If your water heater is over a decade old and has been experiencing frequent and major issues, it's likely time for a replacement. The average lifespan of a traditional tank-style water heater is 8-12 years, so if yours is nearing the end of its life expectancy, it may be more cost-effective to replace it rather than continue repairing it. Additionally, if you notice a significant increase in your energy bills or a decline in the performance of your water heater, these are signs that it's time for a replacement.
Factors to Consider
When deciding whether to replace your water heater, there are a few factors you should keep in mind:
- Age: As mentioned earlier, if your water heater is over a decade old, it's likely time for a replacement. Older units are more prone to breakdowns and may not be as efficient as newer models.
- Cost: If the cost of repairing your water heater is more than half the price of a new one, it may be wiser to invest in a replacement. Continuously spending money on repairs can add up and end up costing you more in the long run.
- Energy Efficiency: Newer water heaters are designed to be more energy-efficient, which can lead to significant savings on your utility bills. If your current unit is old and not energy-efficient, replacing it with a newer model can save you money in the long term.
Specific Signs Your Water Heater Needs Replacement

- Major Leaks: If you notice large puddles of water around your heater, it may indicate significant leaks that require immediate attention.
- Constantly Needs Repair: Frequent breakdowns or persistent issues suggest that your heater might be nearing the end of its lifespan.
- Unusual Noises: Cracks and Pops: Strange sounds like cracking or popping can signal sediment build-up inside the tank, which can lead to inefficiency or further damage.
- No/Low Heat: When your heater fails to provide adequate hot water, it might be due to a malfunctioning heating element or thermostat.
- Metallic Smell/Taste in Water: A metallic taste or smell in your water could indicate that the inside of your heater is corroding, affecting water quality.
- Rusty Colored Water: Discolored or rusty water coming from your taps may be a sign of rust forming inside the heater, compromising its integrity.
- The Heater is More Than 10 Years Old: If your water heater is over a decade old, it might be time to consider a replacement to avoid potential issues and ensure efficient operation.
Ultimately, the decision to repair or replace your water heater will depend on your specific situation and needs. Consulting with a professional plumber can also help you make an informed decision based on their expertise and experience.
What Are My Options For New Water Heaters

When it comes to choosing a new water heater, you have several options to consider. The most common types of water heaters are:
- Conventional storage tank heaters ā These are the traditional models that hold hot water in a large tank until needed.
- Tankless or on-demand heaters ā These units heat water only when needed, making them more energy-efficient.
- Solar-powered heaters ā As the name suggests, these units use solar power to heat the water.
- Heat pump heaters ā This type of heater uses electricity to transfer heat from one place to another, making it more energy-efficient than conventional storage tank heaters.
Ultimately, the best choice for you will depend on your home's unique needs, budget and energy efficiency goals.
In Sacramento and Having Major Water Heater Issues? Call Fix-it Rite!
Fix-it Rite provides 24/7 emergency water heater services to residents in Sacramento, ensuring you're never left without hot water when you need it most. Our team of experienced technicians is skilled at quickly diagnosing and resolving a range of issues, from unusual whining sounds and unpleasant rotten egg smells to low explosive noises emanating from your water heater. We understand how crucial a functioning water heater is to your home, so we prioritize swift and effective service.
For any questions or concerns about your water heater, don't hesitate to contact us at (916) 363-6022. Our friendly customer service team is ready to assist you, and if necessary, a licensed technician will promptly visit your home to assess the situation and find the best solution tailored to your needs.